Most people pick a mortgage term the way they pick a phone plan: they compare the monthly number and take the lower one. That’s understandable, because the monthly payment is what you feel. But the term also decides how much interest you pay over the life of the loan, and the gap is bigger than most people expect.
Here is a worked example, then a way to decide.
The numbers
Take a $320,000 loan at 6.5 percent. This is the same loan we used in how much a mortgage will cost. The rate is only an example. Real rates change often, and a 15-year loan usually carries a lower rate than a 30-year loan, which would widen the gap further. Using the same rate for both keeps the comparison simple.
| 30-year | 15-year | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly principal and interest | About $2,023 | About $2,788 |
| Total paid over the loan | About $728,000 | About $502,000 |
| Total interest | About $408,000 | About $182,000 |
The 15-year payment is about $765 a month higher. In return, you pay roughly $226,000 less in interest, and you own the house outright 15 years sooner.
You can run your own numbers in the Mortgage Calculator.
Why the 30-year costs so much more
On a mortgage, interest is charged on the remaining balance. With a 30-year loan, the balance falls slowly at first, so for the early years most of each payment goes to interest. A shorter loan pays down principal faster, so interest has less time to build up.
That is the whole story. The longer you borrow, the more you pay for the privilege.
Why people still choose 30 years
The 30-year loan isn’t a mistake. It has real advantages.
A lower required payment. You carry less risk if your income drops or an expense hits. A payment you can always make is worth a lot.
Flexibility. You can pay extra when you have it and fall back to the lower required payment when you don’t. A 15-year loan gives you no such room.
Qualifying for more house. Lenders look at your debt-to-income ratio. A common guideline is housing costs under about 28 percent of gross monthly income and total debt under about 36 percent. A lower monthly payment makes it easier to fit within those limits.
Other uses for the money. Some people would rather put the extra $765 toward a 401(k) match, an emergency fund or other debt, especially if those return more than the mortgage costs them.
The middle option: a 30-year loan with extra payments
Here’s a pattern that gets much of the benefit with less risk. Take the 30-year loan, but pay an extra $250 a month toward principal.
On the same loan, that extra $250 pays it off in roughly 22 years and saves about $123,000 in interest. If money gets tight one month, you can drop back to the required payment. Two things to check first: that your loan has no prepayment penalty, and that your lender applies the extra money to principal.
It doesn’t save as much as the 15-year loan, but it costs $515 less a month than the 15-year payment and keeps your options open.
A simple way to decide
Ask these questions in order.
- Could I comfortably afford the 15-year payment, including taxes and insurance, if my income dropped a little? If not, the 15-year loan is too tight.
- Do I have an emergency fund of several months of expenses? If not, build that before speeding up your mortgage.
- Am I getting the full employer match on my 401(k)? That match is usually a better deal than paying down a mortgage early.
- Do I want the flexibility? If yes, take the 30-year loan and pay extra when you can.
If you pass all four and the 15-year payment fits easily, the shorter loan is a good, safe choice. If you’re unsure, the 30-year loan with extra payments is the more forgiving path.
Costs people forget
The principal and interest payment is only part of the cost of owning a home.
- Property tax and homeowners insurance, usually collected monthly and held in escrow
- PMI, if your down payment is under 20 percent on a conventional loan. It can generally be removed once you reach 80 percent equity
- Closing costs, commonly around 2 to 5 percent of the loan amount
- Maintenance, often estimated at about 1 percent of the home’s value per year
Budget for the full cost, not just the loan payment.
If you’re comparing paying extra on a mortgage with investing the difference, the Investment Calculator shows what that money could grow into over time. Returns aren’t guaranteed, so test a few rates.
This article is general information, not financial advice. The numbers above are examples, not rate quotes.
